Xabi Alonso: Real Madrid truly miss Kylian Mbappé when he does not play

Xabi Alonso’s line - that Kylian Mbappé is missed when he does not play - landed like a matchstick in a room full of dry kindling. Real Madrid’s recent league outings, referenced by fans with Alavés and Celta, reopened an old argument: how dependent are Madrid on their new No. 9 for top speed, gravity and ruthless finishing. The replies split fast. Some insisted Madrid should beat mid table sides without him. Others said the attitude on the pitch, not the coach, is the problem. Vinícius, under the microscope, drew both defense and sharp criticism.

A public comment from Xabi Alonso praising Kylian Mbappé’s importance arrived around discussion of Real Madrid’s latest league matches, with supporters invoking fixtures against Alavés and Celta to argue about the team’s reliance on Mbappé and the form of Vinícius Júnior. Madrid navigated a game or games without Mbappé in the lineup, prompting scrutiny of attacking balance and finishing in his absence.

🚨🗣️ Xabi Alonso: “Kylian Mbappé is missed when he doesn’t play.”

@MadridXtra

Impact Analysis

Alonso’s remark is simple and accurate: Mbappé’s presence changes field geometry. At Real Madrid, he stretches the last line, pins both center backs and full backs, and forces teams to defend 15 to 20 meters deeper. That creates time and space for Jude Bellingham between the lines and eases the traffic Vinícius sees on the ball. Without Mbappé, Madrid still create, but the shot quality often dips and so does the volume of clean box touches.

Tactically, Carlo Ancelotti’s favored shape with Mbappé and Vinícius as split forwards and Bellingham as a roaming 10 relies on vertical runs. When Mbappé sits out, Madrid either ask Vinícius to run beyond more often or bring Rodrygo inside to form a narrower pairing. Neither fully replicates Mbappé’s gravity. Opponents then double Vinícius earlier, reduce Madrid’s transition speeds, and crowd the penalty spot on low crosses.

Psychologically, stars matter. Mbappé’s aura shifts how opponents prepare and how teammates choose passes. Even if he has a quiet day, his threat keeps the game tilted. Over a season, those marginal gains show up in late winners, second balls and defensive errors forced by pace. Alonso, who built title winning control at Leverkusen through structure and spacing, recognizes that the fastest way to create space is a world class runner behind. That is Mbappé’s edge, and Madrid feel the difference.

Reaction

Fan reaction online split into familiar camps. One group questioned the narrative, calling Mbappé a ghost in big games and arguing Madrid should handle Alavés without him. Another group backed Alonso’s point, saying the team’s attack loses its edge without the Frenchman and that scapegoating him is lazy. Several comments turned the lens toward effort and attitude, insisting the real issue lies with players on the pitch rather than the coach.

Vinícius Júnior became the lightning rod. Some demanded he be benched after missed chances, others countered that he shoulders double teams and impossible carries when Mbappé is absent. A minority pushed for a different profile up front, asking for a pure shooter to finish moves quicker. There was sarcasm too, with references to whether Mbappé featured against Celta to question outcomes tied solely to one player.

A small number of replies crossed the line with offensive wording, which other supporters condemned. Overall, the tone captured modern Madrid discourse: impatience, high standards, and a fixation on the attack’s end product. Even in wins, the debate keeps circling back to balance, finishing, and the need for a reliable reference point in the box.

Social reactions

your coach said you can't do your job without your boss, 😉

Uta (@albimiamis)

Real Madrid ruined my entire mood. I’m here at midnight, eyes open, carrying heartbreak like a nightshift job.give me my beautiful club

TEMITOPE 30BG (@OlabisoyeT)

I hope he will be ready for the next game.

Imran Khan (@Imran_185)

Prediction

If Mbappé is back for the next league fixtures, expect an immediate uptick in direct runs and clearer separation between the forward line and midfield. Vinícius will see more 1v1s instead of 1v2s, Bellingham will receive facing forward more often, and Madrid’s corners and wide free kicks will become deadlier with a second elite runner attacking the far post. Against compact blocks, Mbappé’s blind side darts are the difference between flat crosses and cutbacks with purpose.

If he remains out, Ancelotti’s cleanest workaround is Rodrygo as a second striker paired tight to Vinícius, with Brahim Díaz floating between lines to add ball retention and final pass quality. Madrid must also lean into late box arrivals from midfield and vary the crossing map: fewer hopeful far post deliveries, more low cutbacks from the byline. Defensively, without Mbappé’s counter threat, Madrid should press higher in curated waves to win shorter fields and keep shot volume healthy.

In the bigger picture, the discourse will simmer until a marquee night. A decisive goal in a tense match will flip the mood fast. Madrid’s ceiling with Mbappé is a title winning attack. Without him, they can still grind, but the margin for error shrinks and the pressure on Vinícius and Bellingham spikes.

Latest today

• Thierry Henry backs Xabi Alonso's methods as Madrid debate intensifies
• Jude Bellingham brushes off England noise: living the dream at Real Madrid
• Mbappé a doubt for Real Madrid vs Alavés - rivals scoff as Los Blancos weigh options
• Xabi Alonso cools talk on Mbappé for Alavés as dressing room closes ranks

Conclusion

Alonso’s line endures because it is grounded in how elite football works. Truly great forwards do more than score. They distort shape, bend decisions, and pull markers into places they do not want to go. Mbappé gives Madrid that distortion on demand. The team can and should beat mid table opposition without him, but the journey is messier and the sequences less clean.

Judging Vinícius solely by missed chances ignores the burden he carries when the defense tilts his way. Judging Mbappé solely by big game myth making overlooks the invisible work that unlocks others. Madrid’s task is to protect their standards regardless of personnel while recognizing why certain pieces are irreplaceable. If the Frenchman is available, the plan is simple: stretch, strike, and suffocate. If not, precision and collective runs must fill the gap. Either way, Alonso’s observation captures the truth of this squad: they are good without Mbappé and dangerous with him.