Rival view: Lisandro Martínez’s ‘early November’ clearance looks wildly optimistic

Reports suggest Lisandro Martínez could be medically cleared in early November, but from a rival’s eye, that sounds like wishful thinking. After a long layoff with a serious knee injury, clearance isn’t the same as match readiness. Expect careful reintroduction, controlled minutes, and bumps along the road—especially with high-intensity fixtures looming. Fans are impatient, dreaming of a swift return for the Liverpool clash, yet the smarter bet is a cautious ramp-up into winter. United can pencil in November, but they’ll likely be erasing and rewriting through December.

An Argentine journalist indicated the defender is tracking for medical clearance in early November following a lengthy knee rehabilitation. The center-back has advanced to on-grass work and controlled team activities, with club staff managing load to protect against secondary muscle issues. Supporters highlighted that nine months post-ACL is the minimum evidence-based reference point, noting increased reinjury risk if rushed. With marquee fixtures on the horizon and United’s defensive inconsistencies exposed, the timeline has become a flashpoint across fan spaces, with some calling for immediate selection and others urging caution.

🚨 BREAKING: Lisandro Martínez is expected to be medically cleared in early November. [@gastonedul]

@UtdXclusive

Impact Analysis

From a rival standpoint, an “early November” green light flatters United more than it helps them. Medical clearance only unlocks the starting gate; it doesn’t close the conditioning gap or erase rust. Martínez’s strengths—aggression on the front foot, left-footed progression, and snap timing in duels—depend on sharpness and repeat power. Those are the last qualities to return after a major knee injury and long layoff.

United’s build-up improves with a natural left-footer, but that benefit is neutralized if his acceleration is half a step off. Opponents will press the return lane relentlessly, force him to open up on the turn, and test diagonal sprints into the channels. The reinjury and soft-tissue risk during the first eight weeks of reintegration is real; even minor hamstring or adductor niggles could stagger his availability into the festive period.

For United, the calculation is cruelly simple: rush him and court setbacks, or wait and sacrifice short-term solidity. Either way, rivals won’t lose sleep. A cautious ramp means more Jonny-come-lately reshuffles at the back; a hasty return invites targeted pressure. In both cases, the competitive edge swings away from Old Trafford in the near term, especially in hostile away fixtures where tempo spikes and transitions punish hesitation.

Reaction

Social buzz split along predictable lines. The cautious camp underscored the nine-month ACL baseline and pointed out that returning earlier can double reinjury risk, arguing for a slow, phased comeback with tight minute management. Another swath of fans simply craved leadership and bite at the back—“can’t wait,” “we miss him”—and one loud faction demanded he be thrown straight into a high-stakes clash. Skeptics rolled their eyes at yet another moving deadline, noting the drip-feed of shifting dates has become a recurring sideshow.

Elsewhere, the timelines were noisy: off-topic entries from other sports and combat promotions drowned threads in non-football hype, muting any nuanced medical debate. Still, the core split remained: pragmatists urging patience versus romantics pushing for instant impact. As a retired pro, I recognize that tension—dressing-room reality respects biomechanics, but fan emotion hunts for a quick fix. United supporters want their enforcer back yesterday; the body, however, tends to keep its own calendar.

Social reactions

Can't wait for his return! 🔥

𝑫𝑭𝑮 (@DFG_UTD)

November marks nine months since his injury, indicating he's on track for recovery. As it's an ACL injury, returning before nine months doubles the reinjury risk. He will also be gradually reintroduced due to potential minor muscle injuries post-ACL.

Deviledred (@creedthered)

There is a different return date for him every other day

Anubhav Maheshwari (@anubhavtuxedo)

Prediction

Three scenarios sit on the table. Best case: Martínez gains medical clearance in early November, logs behind-closed-doors minutes and a controlled cameo late in the month, then builds toward 60–70 minutes by mid-December. He avoids soft-tissue niggles and stabilizes the left half-space. Possible, but optimistic.

Conservative case (most likely): clearance arrives, but staff extend the ramp. He takes bench roles through late November, scattered cameos in early December, then starts intermittently around the festive period. Expect one precautionary absence as loads spike. Full match sharpness doesn’t truly appear until January.

Setback case: the knee proves sound, but reactive hamstring/adductor tightness interrupts progression. That pauses training intensity and pushes real contributions into late January or even February. Given his combative style and United’s chaotic defensive phases, this is hardly far-fetched. As a rival, I’d mark the calendar for a winter return to form—not November—then plan pressing traps to stress-test his first contacts and turning radius the moment he’s back.

Latest today

• Bayern poised to recall Daniel Peretz in January after Hamburg benching Bayern poised to recall Daniel Peretz in January after Hamburg benching
• Barcelona fast-track 16-year-old Baba Kourouma: left-footed CB trains with Hansi Flick’s first team Barcelona fast-track 16-year-old Baba Kourouma: left-footed CB trains with Hansi Flick’s first team
• Galatasaray close in on Tyrell Malacia as January move gathers momentum Galatasaray close in on Tyrell Malacia as January move gathers momentum
• Barcelona set to let Robert Lewandowski leave on a free this summer: exit all but certain Barcelona set to let Robert Lewandowski leave on a free this summer: exit all but certain

Conclusion

Strip away the noise and the headline reads like spin. Early November medical clearance sounds handy on paper, but it doesn’t win duels or carry the ball through a press. The smart interpretation is that United are months away—not weeks—from a fully humming Lisandro Martínez. Between load management, match rhythm, and inevitable micro-issues, his first starts will be carefully rationed and easy to target.

From where I’m sitting—as someone who’s felt the long road back—rivals should relish the window. Press the left channel, bait aggressive steps into space, and force repeated recovery sprints. If United rush him, the odds of a stutter grow; if they hold him back, that’s more time their back line stays vulnerable. Either way, the immediate balance tilts away from Old Trafford. Pencil in November if you must—but the ink won’t dry until deep winter.