Man United undeterred as Brighton set 2027 stance on Carlos Baleba - pathway to a deal is clear

Brighton’s internal stance is not to sell Carlos Baleba until 2027, yet Manchester United are calm and optimistic. From what I’m hearing, United believe a structured bid - upfront fee plus add-ons and a sell-on - can shift the conversation this summer. Baleba’s profile fits United’s midfield like a glove: ball-winning, athletic, press resistant, simple but forward passing. Having played that role, I see why the recruitment team is persistent. Brighton will demand a premium, that’s their model, but there’s a deal to be done when the project and price align. Expect patient talks, clear roles, and a decisive push late in the window.

UK broadsheet reporting has outlined Brighton’s plan to keep Carlos Baleba in-house until at least 2027, reflecting the club’s usual stance of controlling timing and value in the market. The message mirrors how Brighton previously handled interest in their key midfielders, prioritizing development and price discipline. Meanwhile, Manchester United have been actively assessing central midfield options for the upcoming window, with internal discussions focused on adding a high-energy ball-winner to complement their current core. This is a classic Premier League negotiation setup: a selling club with firm pricing principles and a buying club ready to structure a serious proposal.

🚨 BREAKING: Brighton’s plan is not to sell Carlos Baleba until 2027. [@JNorthcroft, @TimesSport]

@UtdXclusive

Impact Analysis

For Brighton, planting a 2027 marker does two things. First, it stabilizes the dressing room by publicly backing a young midfielder they rate highly. Second, it sets the negotiation floor. Historically, Brighton convert these stances into leverage that maximizes future fees, maintaining their reputation for selling on their terms. It also buys them time to elevate Baleba’s minutes and value through a defined development plan.

For Manchester United, the message is a hurdle, not a wall. United’s need profile is clear: a rangy, press-resistant ball-winner who can anchor transitions and allow their creators to play higher. Baleba offers that balance. He covers space aggressively, breaks up play without diving into reckless challenges, and plays forward early. He is not a tempo dictator yet, but he is the ground-covering foundation that modern Premier League midfields require.

Financially, this points toward a layered bid. Brighton rarely budge without premiums, but they respond to smart structures: significant guaranteed fee, performance add-ons tied to starts and European qualification, plus a sell-on clause. If United package all three, the gap narrows quickly. Competitive dynamics matter too: if other top clubs circle, Brighton’s position strengthens. If United move decisively before a broader auction forms, they gain control. Net result: the stance raises the price but does not shut the door.

Reaction

Fan sentiment split quickly. A common thread among United fans is summed up by a comment that Brighton are just being Brighton - tough negotiators whose stance often signals a high price rather than a true no-sale policy. Some supporters shrug and say keep him, while others argue he’s the upgrade the midfield needs and urge the club to get it done. There are practical questions too: if not Baleba, then who, and how soon?

On Brighton’s side, the reaction is proud and pragmatic. They’ve seen this movie before and know their model works. Keep the player until he’s fully ready, then sell for top value. A couple of sharper comments take aim at the posturing of big clubs, but most accept that a premium is the correct outcome if talks ever reach the table.

Noise in the thread around AFCON shoutouts, Garnacho being pressed by Lewis Miley, and quips about Mainoo’s shirt show the usual matchday crossfire. Strip that away and the core sentiment is clear: United fans want a combative, modern 6-8 profile, and Baleba ticks the boxes. Brighton fans trust their process and won’t blink without a proper proposal. That tension fuels the market - and drives deals when the numbers rise.

Social reactions

They can keep him, or pay us 10m to take him

The Grandmaster (@theredarmy2436)

Ya see what there doing hes having a bad season so there hoping if he stays longer his proce will increase silly keeping a unhappy player

RedIrishDub (@RedIrishDub)

Sounds like Brighton being Brighton. If they don’t want to sell, fair enough ..but that usually just means the price will be crazy. Baleba’s a top talent though, so I get why we’re looking.

Old Trafford Updates (@news_united_)

Prediction

I expect Manchester United to push ahead with Baleba as a priority target and open channels formally before the summer window intensifies. The first offer will likely test Brighton’s resolve with a healthy guaranteed fee and smart add-ons. The turning point comes if United include a strong sell-on - Brighton value future upside as much as headline numbers.

Tactically, this is too clean a fit to ignore. Pairing a high-energy ball-winner with United’s young technical core gives the team balance they’ve lacked in transition. It reduces exposure in defensive phases and lets their creators start higher. From my time in midfield, I know how a single destroyer who can play cleanly transforms the whole structure - pressing triggers hit quicker, counterpress bite improves, and the back four defend fewer open-field runs.

Two scenarios: 1) United close a deal late in the window after incremental bids and a breakthrough on add-ons and sell-on. 2) If Brighton’s number stretches beyond club-record territory, United park talks temporarily while keeping Baleba warm and pivot to a parallel target, then return late if the landscape softens. My call: Scenario 1 wins out. Expect a patient negotiation that ends with United landing their man.

Latest today

• Bruno Fernandes €60m clause shuts out Premier League - PSG primed for summer move
• Exclusive: Kobbie Mainoo set for targeted loan to accelerate minutes, with a clear route b...
• Manchester United pitch project to Antoine Semenyo after positive talks - January move gat...
• Real Madrid squad vs Sevilla: Fede Valverde out - Mbappé and Bellingham to shoulder the lo...

Conclusion

Brighton’s 2027 line is smart, measured, and utterly consistent with how they operate. But it is also a starting point for negotiation. United’s need is immediate, their profile is specific, and Baleba is the right age and skill set to grow with a project that demands legs, discipline, and simple forward passes under pressure.

I’ve sat in recruitment rooms and watched how this plays out. A buying club identifies a keystone profile and keeps knocking, not with noise but with structure. The moment the offer feels like a pathway rather than an exit, talks move. Brighton protect value, United secure a fit, and the player steps into a bigger role with a clear plan.

So yes, the headline says 2027. The football logic says summer. United will stay respectful, Brighton will stay firm, and somewhere in the middle sits a deal that suits everyone. I expect United to finish this - and when they do, the midfield will look immediately more balanced.