Kevin Muscat to Rangers stalls after talks with Patrick Stewart and Kevin Thelwell — optimism still high

Kevin Muscat’s expected appointment as Rangers manager has encountered a brief pause following high-level discussions with Patrick Stewart and Kevin Thelwell. Negotiations are understood to be focused on structure, recruitment alignment and staffing, rather than finances. Despite the slowdown, signals remain positive that Rangers and Muscat can reach agreement, with the Ibrox club prioritising a high-press, front-foot coach and the current Shanghai Port boss fitting that profile. Online reaction has been fierce, with sections of the fanbase venting at decision-makers, yet the overarching industry view suggests a deal remains very much alive. Next 48–72 hours are considered pivotal.

The development follows detailed conversations between Kevin Muscat’s camp and senior decision-makers, including Patrick Stewart and Kevin Thelwell, to clarify football structure, recruitment responsibilities and the composition of the backroom team. Muscat, currently in charge of Shanghai Port and previously a title-winner in Japan, has long been admired for his aggressive pressing and transition-focused style. The latest round of talks introduced additional layers around process and autonomy, slowing the timeline but not derailing it. Fan chatter has intensified, with calls for boardroom changes trending, while club insiders continue to brief that alignment is achievable with further dialogue.

Kevin Muscat's appointment as #Rangers manager is stalling following talks with Patrick Stewart and Kevin Thelwell. More on https://t.co/ZRTBbuiXmA wih @JacobsBen

@alex_crook

Impact Analysis

If concluded, Muscat’s arrival would represent a clear statement of intent from Rangers: a return to an assertive, high-tempo identity that aligns with the squad’s athletic profile and the league’s week-to-week demands. His blueprint—compact distances, rapid regains, and verticality in transition—could extract more from energetic wide players and mobile No.8s, while reintroducing a clear pressing trigger framework out of possession. This would likely require immediate conditioning tweaks and role clarity for centre-backs comfortable defending space, plus a goalkeeper confident in initiating quick restarts.

Structurally, the pause underscores a crucial modern reality: without crystal-clear recruitment governance and shared KPIs, even the best tactical fit can underperform. Ensuring seamless integration between head coach, data and scouting departments will be decisive, particularly for January and summer windows where two to three stylistically aligned additions (a ball-carrying full-back, a press-resistant midfielder, and a runner in behind) could raise the ceiling quickly.

Commercially, a Muscat appointment would energise matchday narratives and international interest, especially given his track record in Asia and links to progressive coaching schools. The risk, if talks drag, is a perception of drift that can spook targets and embolden rivals; yet the upside, if closed swiftly, is a unifying message that Rangers have a coherent plan and the conviction to execute it.

Reaction

Fan sentiment is running hot. A vocal contingent has pivoted from excitement to exasperation, arguing that decision-making at the top is overcomplicating a straightforward hire. Comments calling for leadership changes and the hashtag wave (#THELWELLOUT, #STEWARTOUT) reflect a frustration cycle that often accompanies modern managerial chases. One supporter joked that scouting Shanghai Port on a weekday morning now feels like wasted effort—capturing both anticipation and annoyance in a single breath. Others simply asked what went wrong, highlighting a vacuum of official updates.

Yet there is another strand of reaction: pragmatic fans accept that elite appointments hinge on alignment—particularly on recruitment control, analytics input, and backroom staffing. They view a short delay as a price worth paying for long-term stability. This more measured cohort notes Muscat’s track record in building high-intensity teams and believes his principles mirror what the Ibrox crowd craves.

Overall, the discourse splits between urgency and assurance: one side wants immediate confirmation, the other prefers a watertight framework before pen meets paper. Both sides agree on one thing—Muscat’s profile fits the identity they want to see restored.

Social reactions

Why what’s happened ?

Sheik ma haun (@71malks)

#THELWELLOUT #STEWARTOUT

Archie (@NZblanc)

Thelwell and Stewart out now !!!

SH 1872 (@sh_1872)

Prediction

Base case: a rapid reset of talks delivers agreement on reporting lines and recruitment sign-off, paving the way for Muscat’s unveiling. Expect swift moves to secure trusted assistants and an early technical audit of the squad. That sequence would likely trigger a targeted shortlist for upcoming windows and a preseason geared to aerobic load and pressing drills.

Alternative scenario: if autonomy and staffing prove sticking points, Rangers may reopen dialogue with previously screened candidates to maintain leverage. Even then, Muscat would remain in the frame provided there is flexibility on both sides. In this track, interim planning intensifies to avoid calendar slippage in scouting and contract cycles.

Lower-probability path: Muscat stays at Shanghai Port through a longer horizon, forcing Rangers to pivot completely. This would place premium value on candidates with prebuilt staff and plug-and-play models. Regardless of pathway, expect Rangers to prioritise a coach with aggressive out-of-possession principles, demonstrating the club’s strategic commitment to a proactive identity.

Latest today

• Real Madrid set collaborative timeline for Nico Paz and Chema returns Real Madrid set collaborative timeline for Nico Paz and Chema returns
• Florian Wirtz benching rumor sparks debate: €150m talk, Liverpool links and selection storm Florian Wirtz benching rumor sparks debate: €150m talk, Liverpool links and selection storm
• Rival view: Gnabry’s ‘minor’ adductor injury looks bigger — Brugge clash in real doubt Rival view: Gnabry’s ‘minor’ adductor injury looks bigger — Brugge clash in real doubt
• Ruben Amorim stance: Zirkzee and Mainoo deemed untouchable as 2026 World Cup looms Ruben Amorim stance: Zirkzee and Mainoo deemed untouchable as 2026 World Cup looms

Conclusion

The pause is real, but so too is the momentum. All indications point to talks centring on structure, not suitability, and on clarity, not cold feet. Muscat remains an excellent stylistic match—his teams are front-foot, data-friendly and ruthlessly organised in transitions. That blueprint fits the Ibrox mandate and the competitive rhythm of the Scottish Premiership.

Rangers’ task in the coming days is straightforward: lock down the governance details, empower the head coach within a transparent recruitment framework and announce with conviction. Do that, and the noise recedes quickly, replaced by on-pitch benchmarks and incremental wins in training-ground habits. Miss that window, and the narrative swings to drift—a risk the club appears intent on avoiding.

Expect clarity soon. The smart money remains on Rangers and Muscat finding common ground and moving decisively, setting the tone for a summer of targeted reinforcement and a sharper, more aggressive identity at Ibrox.